What should you collect first under the order of volatility?
An analyst arrives at a workstation that is still powered on. Alerts suggest it is running malware that exists only in memory. The analyst has approval to collect evidence and has started a chain of custody form. Following the order of volatility, which evidence should the analyst collect first?
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: D. The contents of system memory (RAM)
The order of volatility tells you to collect evidence that disappears fastest before evidence that lasts. Memory (RAM) is lost the moment the computer loses power. Here, the malware lives only in memory, so a memory capture may be the only place it can be found.
A common order, based on RFC 3227, from most to least volatile:
- CPU registers and cache
- Routing table, ARP cache, process table, kernel statistics and memory (RAM)
- Temporary file systems and swap space
- Disk
- Remote logging and monitoring data
- Physical configuration and network topology
- Archive media, such as backups
CPU registers and cache are even more volatile than RAM, but they are not one of the choices. Of the four options, RAM is the most volatile.
Why the other options are wrong
- A. A full image of the hard drive: The disk is important evidence, but data on a disk survives a shutdown. It is less volatile than memory, so it comes later.
- B. Logs already sent to the central log server: Those logs are stored on another system. Nothing that happens to this workstation will change them, so they are low on the volatility list.
- C. Last week's backup tapes: Backups and archive media are the least volatile evidence. They can wait until the end.
Grab what dies first. If pulling the plug would erase it, collect it now. Hot to cold: CPU, memory, disk, remote logs, backups.
Exam objective 4.8: Explain appropriate incident response activities.